They are currently members of the Northern Counties East League Premier Division and play their home games at Norwood Park.

In 1954 a further merger with Beverley United occurred and the club became a highly-competitive side on the East Riding County League scene for the next two decades.

After disagreements with the grounds committee, the club left Norwood around 1970 and a nomadic existence was to follow, with Beverley Town sides continuing to play in the East Riding County League at various venues over the ensuing years.

These included the former Victoria Barracks – now a Morrisons Supermarket; the Hodgsons Recreation Ground, Longcroft School, and Orchard Park playing fields in nearby Hull.

The club lifted its first Humber Premier title in 2012–13 – under manager Dave Ricardo and coach Steve Mulligan, losing only one game in the process.

The following season, on 11 May 2024, the club was promoted to the NCEL Premier League after a thrilling penalty shootout in a play-off final against Shirebrook Town.

This came after Beverley Town accumulated 103 points during the regular season which saw them secure the league runner-up position behind Parkgate FC.

These include former Leeds, Tottenham, and England goalkeeper, Paul Robinson, as well as former Hull City players, John Hawley; Ray Clubley, Linton Brown, Darren France, and Gavin Kelly.