The predominant rivalry for the show was a confrontation for the JCW Heavyweight Championship between the champion Corporal Robinson, Mike Knox, and Raven.

[5] In the two following years, D'Amore brought in several competitors to attempt to defeat Corporal Robinson for the championship, but all had failed.

[6] The two continued to battle throughout the season, leading to Robinson defeating Raven in a Ladder match at Bloodymania II.

At Big Ballas X-Mas Party '08, the Thomaselli Brothers disguised themselves as The Ring Rydas and defeated The Bump-N-Uglies to win the JCW Tag Team Championship.

[9] On June 3, 2010, as part of a storyline, the Thomaselli Brothers were renamed The Haters by Juggalo Championship Wrestling owners Insane Clown Posse due to their villainous actions.

Officer Colt Cabana first appeared in Juggalo Championship Wrestling through a promo in which he spoke of keeping order and forcing fans to show respect for the law.

[13] In the third episode of season two, Tracy caught his illegitimate daughter Isabella listening to Boondox, the rapper who sings 2 Tuff Tony's entrance music.

[14] The following week, Smothers caught Isabella engaging in sexual actions with Boondox, through storyline, and assaulted him.

[5] At Bloodymania II, the team of 2 Tuff Tony and Boondox defeated Tracy Smothers and Bull Pain.

[1] Mahoney and teammate Hollywood Chuck Hogan were booked to face Mad Man Pondo and Necro Butcher in a tag team Ultra-Deathmatch, where there was no disqualifications and the use of weapons was encouraged.

[17][18] Prior to the next match, per storyline, Shawn Daivari attacked one of his opponents Road Dogg Jesse James backstage.

The end saw Sabu interfere and perform a diving leg drop with a steel chair onto Daivari, allowing Joey Ryan to pick up the pinfall.

[17] In the following match, Isis scored a pinfall after lifting Isabella by her neck then slamming her back to the mat.

[17] In the final preliminary match, Balls Mahoney and Hollywood Chuck Hogan faced Mad Man Pondo and Necro Butcher in a tag team Ultra-Deathmatch.

As Raven attempted the move a second time, Corporal Robinson grabbed him and applied a cobra clutch.

Juggalo World Order member Sid Vicious came down and threw the duo back into the ring.