Kelsey spent three years as an assistant coach at Virginia Tech before returning to her alma mater prior to the 2007-08 campaign.
She has also held assistant coaching positions at Western Carolina, Evansville, Florida, and Boise State.
Kelsey won the 2022 Milwaukee Public Schools Employee Golf League Championship, playing for Team Central Services .
In 2023, incomplete paperwork led to the Riverside High School swim team being unable to compete in their sectional meet for the 2022–23 season.
In 2024 the Pulaski and Bay View high school football teams were forced to forfeit multiple games, as well as incur two-year postseason bans because of missing paperwork.