The Terriers and Crusaders have a program-wide rivalry called the Turnpike Trophy, which BU leads 2–0 as of 2017.

BU and Holy Cross had been conference rivals in the past prior to the former joining the Patriot League in 2013.

Head-to-head games/matches only Now in the same conference, the two schools agreed to face off for the Turnpike Trophy across all sports in 2015.

In general, each head-to-head contest between the two schools in each sport is worth a single point in the standings.

In sports that do not have head-to-head competition such as cross country, track & field, swimming & diving, rowing, and golf, 1 point is awarded to the school that finishes higher at the Patriot League Championships.