The team was a member of the Central Ontario Junior C Hockey League early on.

The Eagles won the Clarence Schmalz Cup as Ontario Hockey Association Junior "C" Champions in 1981.

After their 3rd straight league title in 1995, the Eagles under the guidance of Mike Laing, the General Manager and eventual owner during the winning years of the 1990s, made the jump to the OPJHL.

The team was sold by Mike Laing mid season in 1998 to Peter Neal and Scott Mackie from Whitby, Ontario.

From 1995 until 2003, the Eagles achieved moderate results, never pushing much further than a barely winning record.