Dutton played for the Brisbane Bandits and Queensland Rams, where in the 2006 Claxton Shield he won the Helms Award, given to Most Valuable Player.
He is the elder brother of current Brisbane Bandits and Australia national baseball team player Wade Dutton.
He played for the Australia national baseball team in the 2008 Final Olympic Qualification Tournament, replacing Reading Phillies shortstop, Brad Harman while he was busy at spring training.
Dutton returned to Rockford for a third season in 2008 and batted .311, narrowly missing out on the top 10 in the Frontier League for average.
Following his ABL career, Dutton continued to play for the Redcliffe Padres and then Ipswich Musketeers in the Greater Brisbane League, before retiring in 2019.