She was traded in 2018 to the Utah Royals FC of the National Women's Soccer League (NWSL), however she decided to take time off from her professional career.

[citation needed] Taylor also played for club teams, North Rockland Lady Storm and Albertson Express.

She scored the match-winning goal in the second overtime of the Huskies' first round match-up against Boston University in the 2009 NCAA Tournament.

[citation needed] After the WPS suspended operations in 2012, Taylor joined the New York Fury in the WPSL Elite.

[12] In 2013, Taylor signed with the Western New York Flash for the inaugural season of the National Women's Soccer League.

[15] Taylor was traded from the Western New York Flash to FC Kansas City in November 2015 in exchange for Rebecca Moros.

Taylor led a defense which shut down Christine Sinclair and the Canadian team to win a silver medal.