Founded in 2023, the club began play in 2024, and will field a men's team in the USL Championship (USLC) beginning in 2026.

[4][5] Among the minority owners in North Sixth Group are television personality Kelly Ripa and actor Mark Consuelos.

[10] The club originally announced a kit deal with Kappa, but after the ownership group acquired a stake in manufacturer Diaza, the contract was transferred.

[19] The league released its season schedule on May 30, 2024, establishing the club's inaugural match would be on Saturday, August 31, a home game against Carolina Ascent FC.

[20] Brooklyn FC announced on May 17, 2024 that they had signed the first-ever player in club history, Puerto Rican national team goalkeeper Sydney Martinez.

Note: Flags indicate national team as defined under FIFA eligibility rules; some limited exceptions apply.

Top goalscorer(s) includes all goals scored in League, and USL Super Cup Playoffs, and other competitive matches.

[3] The Academy’s U23 team started play in the semi-professional United Premier Soccer League (UPSL) 2024 as Brooklyn FC II.