During his four-year tenure at Connecticut, Hancock's accomplishments were leading the Huskies to an NCAA Division I National Championship in 2000.
To add to his list of achievements Hancock was named Big East Goalkeeper of the Year in 2001 as well as earning All-American status.
After failing to appear in a single match for the Galaxy, Hancock was released from his contract and signed with the Atlanta Silverbacks of the A-League on April 19, 2002.
In the earlier stages of the season he competed with Richard Goddard for the starting position, but ultimately was made the Lynx's first choice goaltender.
He made his Toronto debut on April 17, 2004, in a 1–0 victory over the Puerto Rico Islanders, where he recorded his first clean sheet of the season.