The song was written by Nashville songwriters Rodney Clawson and Brent Anderson, and one of the two tracks on the album that Crow did not have a hand in writing.

The song was Taste of Country's Critic's Pick for October 13, 2013 and was praised by critic Billy Dukes, who compared the song to Lady Antebellum's "Need You Now", writing that "(you) have to listen a few times to realize you don't miss the heavy-handed production that sensationalizes and sexualizes similar efforts.

"[2] Tara Toro from Got Country Online gave the song 4 stars out of 5, writing: "Sheryl's voice conveys the feelings of loneliness and vulnerability believably", also stating that "this song (and album) should assist her in becoming a mainstay in the genre".

[3] Enio Chiola from Pop Matters wrote that "It's so freakin' catchy and rings out with a home-hitting familiarity that you can't help but think: Why does he always gotta be callin' me when I'm lonely?".

[7] The single debuted at number 52 on the Billboard Country Airplay chart for the week of November 16, 2013.