Born in Arima, Mitchell began his career in the TT Pro League with Joe Public in 2008.

[2] He signed with Vancouver Whitecaps FC of Major League Soccer on 15 September 2011,[3] making his debut for the club on 6 October 2011.

[7][8] In July 2017, he signed for Indian I-League club East Bengal after a brief spell with San Juan Jabloteh,[9] and appeared in the Calcutta Football League.

[11] However, he left shortly after and signed with Indy Eleven on 12 February 2018, alongside Central teammate Nathan Lewis.

[2] He scored his first goal for the national side in a 2018 FIFA World Cup Qualification 3–1 loss to Honduras on 15 November 2016.