A news article from the Mornington Standard in 1909 reported the formation of the 'Carrum Football Club' with R. W. Jones elected as President and M. McCauley and A. Rigby as Vice-Presidents.

They reformed and joined the Peninsula District Football Association where they won their second premiership in 1932 in their return season.

Following this Carrum entered a rebuilding stage and yielded little success until 1959 when great efforts were made to match the strength of sides such as Hastings, Frankston and Crib Point.

In the late 1960s the club song was changed to It's a Grand Old Flag, as used by the Melbourne Demons in the Australian Football League.

1974 premiership captain Gary Guy made the move to the VFL in 1975, eventually playing 22 matches for the Melbourne Football Club.

For a short period of time between 1957 and 1962 Carrum Football Club wore blue and gold hoops similar to the Geelong jumper.

Reforming in 2013, as a tribute to over 100 years of football in the Carrum community the current playing Guernsey pays homage to the Guernsey worn when the Carrum Football Club won back to back MPFL premierships in 1973 and 1974.

[5] In all, Carrum Patterson Lakes Football Club has won 12 premierships and finished runners up 12 times.