The first published articles linked on the site included ones by co-founders Brian Burch and Joshua Mercer.

[16] On June 25, 2015, one day before same-sex marriage became legal everywhere in the United States, CatholicVote.org uploaded a video onto YouTube called "Not Alone".

[17][18] According to Catholic News Agency, many websites condemned the video, calling the participants "bigots" or "anti-gay".

"[19] In June 2022, CatholicVote.org urged parents to check out any LGBT-themed books from their local libraries so that no children would be able to see them.

[6] In 2010, CatholicVote.org organized a petition urging the United States Postal Service to issue a Mother Teresa commemorative stamp despite opposition by the Freedom From Religion Foundation and similar groups.