[1] He joined the World League of American Football (WLAF)'s Frankfurt Galaxy in 1997.
He also earned all-league honors as a shortstop on the baseball team, hitting .489 as a senior.
May earned All-Big Eight honors in 1993 and 1994 while leading Kansas State to back-to-back bowl appearances.
He passed for 2,571 yards in 1994 as Kansas State went 9-3 and lost 12–7 to Boston College in the 1994 Aloha Bowl.
He also set a school single-game record with 489 passing yards in a 45–28 loss to Nebraska in 1993.