[18] Following an injury to Alex Latta sustained in a friendly against Third Lanark, Daniel Kirkwood was moved to outside right with Parry being recalled at centre half for the match against Derby County on 4 October.

[20] Parry was eventually recalled to the team on Boxing Day taking over from Campbell at left half in the 3–2 victory against Accrington Stanley[21] retaining his place in the side for the rest of the season.

[24] Parry played at left-half in the first match of the 1891–92 season, a 4–0 defeat at West Bromwich Albion[25] but then lost his place to Alex Lochhead.

"[27] Parry appears to have temporarily joined Ardwick AFC playing eleven times (scoring once) between November 1891 and January 1892.

[30] Parry was re-engaged by Everton in December 1892, on wages of £2 per week[31] and returned to the first team in January 1893, when he took over from Jimmy Jamieson at left back for the match at Sunderland.

[36][37] For the 1893–94 season, manager Dick Molyneux used a reasonably settled first team, with eleven players appearing in 20 or more of the 30 league matches.

[41] Parry retained his place in the side for a further seven matches, switching to left back on Howarth's return, but was replaced by Dickie Boyle on 24 March, after a run of four defeats.

[38] Following the departure of Bob Howarth at the start of the 1894–95 season, Parry "made the left back his own"[43] with former Scotland international James Adams alongside him on the right.

[46] In this match, Jack Bell scored a hat-trick for Everton but Parry conceded a penalty by "deliberately handling" the ball in the area.

[47] In his six years at Everton, Parry made 94 appearances in Football League and FA Cup matches, scoring five goals.

[48] Following a short-lived move to Ardwick, for whom he made no first-team appearances,[1] Parry returned to Wales in December 1895 when he took a public house, called the Oak Vaults,[49] in Newtown and joined the local club,[3] then playing in the Shropshire League.

[52] In 1899, Parry joined Aberystwyth Town;[3] during his season there, he again reached the Welsh Cup Final, defeating Druids 3–0 to take the trophy.

[3] In April 1904, Parry was again the beneficiary of a testimonial match when Liverpool visited Park Hall to play Oswestry Town.

[57] In their annual player assessment, the Football Association of Wales described Parry in 1891 as "a good half back but out of condition and got injured; played a splendid game v.

[3] At the Everton board meeting on 7 February, a letter was read from the vicar of Oswestry informing the club of Parry's death.

[69] He was buried at Oswestry Cemetery in an unmarked grave; with help of contribution by the Everton FC Heritage Society a headstone was unveiled on 1 March 2019.