Following the end of the regular season, Odoi-Atsem earned First Team All-Big Ten Conference honors.
During his junior year, Odoi-Atsem achieved Second Team All-Big Ten Conference honors and made 20 appearances for the Terrapins.
As a senior, Odoi-Atsem was part of a Maryland squad that spent most of the 2016 NCAA Division I men's soccer season ranked first in the country.
[12] He returned to the field after his battle with cancer on 29 May 2019, playing 67 minutes in a game against Chicago Fire.
[16] In July 2023, Odoi-Atsem made an appearance for National Premier Soccer League side Alexandria Reds.
[18] In October 2018, Odoi-Atsem was diagnosed with Stage 2 Hodgkin's Lymphoma, effectively ending his 2018 season with D.C. United as he began a chemotherapy regimen at MedStar Georgetown University Hospital.