The building underwent exterior restoration in 1991 and 1992, and it was designated as a New York City landmark.

He was the first to permit attendance of black children from a nearby "Negro orphan asylum".

[5] Members of Christ Church today are drawn to the congregation's vibrant diversity, with people who have come together from many different countries and many faith traditions to form a warm and supportive community.

Andrew G. Butler III is since 2014 the Rector of Christ Church Riverdale, after serving parishes in New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and Virginia.

In June 1941 the church was the site of the funeral of former New York Yankee baseball player Lou Gehrig, whose home was nearby.