But, they had a forgetful debut outing as the Goan outfit was knocked out in the very first round by Vietnamese club Dong Thap with a 2–1 aggregate loss.

[34] Through their I-League win Churchill Brothers FC were able to play in the 2010 Asian Champions League qualifiers which they lost and moved to the 2010 AFC Cup.

[36] The club went the rest of the season with Croatian Drago Mamić, who helped them win the IFA Shield that year.

[39][40] His start proved to be successful as the club captured the 2011 Durand Cup for the third time in their history in October 2011, defeating Prayag United 5–4.

[45] After his first season in charge, Dias managed to lead Churchill Brothers to the I-League championship,[46][47][48] their second domestic title in the history.

[56] Churchill then roped in Joseph Afusi of Nigeria as technical director,[57] but were relegated at the end of the 2017–18 season, with just 17 points from 18 games.

[67][68][69][70] Although Churchill managed a win against RoundGlass Punjab in their last match, Gokulam Kerala FC were crowned champions courtesy of a better head-to-head record.

[71][72] Ahead of the 2021–22 I-League, Churchill roped in their first ever Guinean player Sekou Sylla,[73] and Romanian Petre Gigiu returned to the club as head coach.

[75][76] The club later in November, reached final of Baji Rout Cup in Odisha,[77] finished as runners-up after defeat to Rajasthan United.

[78] They later took part in 2023 Indian Super Cup in Kerala in April,[79] and 2024 Bhausaheb Bandodkar Memorial Trophy along with foreign teams like Brisbane Roar and Defensa y Justicia participated.

[111] During the 2013 AFC Cup, Churchill Brothers used Shri Shiv Chhatrapati Sports Complex in Pune as their home ground.

[123] Note: Flags indicate national team as defined under FIFA eligibility rules; some limited exceptions apply.

[261][262] Club's midfielder Cia Ryzella Almeida was honoured with "Women's Player of the Year" award by Goa Football Association (GFA) in June 2023.