The underperforming continued into the following events for the Subliners, ultimately leading to the team's first roster change; in which they acquired "Mack".

[8] The Call of Duty team of NYSL had been struggling for a while before they picked up a player named KiSMET, who had been making waves in the competitive scene for his exceptional skills.

[15] After the departure of Crimsix, the New York Subliners built their roster for the 2023 Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2 season around Hydra, making two significant additions in the form of players Priestahh and Skyz.

[16] At the first tournament of the season, Major 1 hosted by the league in Raleigh, North Carolina, NYSL won the top seat.

After winning the MW2 championship, The New York Subliners dropped Priestahh and added Sib to their professional lineup for the MW3 Season.

During the At the fourth tournament of the season, Major 4 hosted by the league in Burbank, California, NYSL won the top seat.

In October 2024, Cloud9 New York built their roster around Sib with additions of Attach, Kremp, and Mack with Accuracy as the new head coach.

On January 25, 2024, NYSL announced that they would be creating a semi-professional team (Tier 2) for Call of Duty Challengers Cup, featuring players Gunless, Classic, PaulEhx, and Decemate.