By the 1860s, Clover Hill had its own post office, school, church, distillery, and general store.

In 1841, another settler named John S. Craig organized what would eventually become the Clover Hill Presbyterian Church.

After the Civil War, a physician named Samuel Gault set up a practice at Clover Hill, and served as the community's post master.

In 1887, two millers named "Martin" and "West" owned and operated the Clover Hill Mill.

The Clover Hill Mill is a 2+1⁄2-story structure with a metal, gable roof, weatherboard siding, and a concrete foundation.

The concrete foundation of the original mill's overshot wheel is located behind the present structure.