The historic two-story red brick building located at 780 Seashore Road in the Cold Spring section of Lower Township, in Cape May County, New Jersey.

The current church building, known as "Old Brick", was constructed in 1823[3] by Thomas H. Hughes, who was also the architect of Congress Hall in Cape May, New Jersey.

The church was added to the National Register of Historic Places on June 14, 1991, for its significance in settlement, architecture, religion, and government.

Hughston Hughes was pastor for one year, starting in 1726, before being dismissed for "his too free use of intoxicating drinks.

His tombstone in the adjacent graveyard was inscribed In yonder sacred house I spent my breath,Now, silent, mouldering here I lie in death,Those silent lips shall wake and yet declare,A dread amen to truths they publish there[4] The two hundredth anniversary of the church was celebrated on August 16, 1914.