[1][2] The CMA was organized by boys themselves, in imitation of the fraternities or lodges of older persons, and was exploited by a magazine mainly as a device for extending circulation.

[3] In the summer of 1892, Joseph R. Hunter,[4] at that time a boy in his teens, organized a "secret society" among his friends and class at Oak Park, Illinois.

It began as a school children's club, under the auspices and with the active co-operation of the brother, a thirty-second degree Freemason, who was at the same time an Odd Fellow, a Mystic Shriner, and a member of several other secret societies.

[1] The older brother was called upon to assist in preparing the secret work and initiation,[2] in imitation of such ideas of Masons, Odd-Fellows, and others.

On March 13, 1895, it was granted a certificate and charter by the state of Illinois, which gave it the power to enroll members, organize lodges, and conduct meetings.

[5] Unlike some other secret societies, degrees were conferred for work for the lodge, deeds of bravery, and other imilar actions.

Instead of this, each member, to keep in good standing, was required to keep up his subscription to The Star Monthly, the official organ, and the traveling card which was sent him each time he renews, was the proof that he was in good-standing.

Departments included Athletics, Games, Carpentry, Mechanics, Electricity, Puzzles, History, Photography, Coins, Curios, Stamps, and Amateur Journalism.