Several of the structures from Lynce's landing were also retained, including a farmhouse on the property that was converted to a hotel.

Ownership of the park transferred to the Pittsburgh & Shenango Valley Railroad in 1901, during which time several hotels were built on the property.

With its lakefront presence, hotels, and remote location, the park became a popular resort destination.

[4] Although many of the park's original buildings were lost in a fire in 1908, new concrete block replacements were constructed, including the Dreamland Ballroom.

[4] "Fairyland Forest," a walk-through attraction, was constructed across the highway from the park's main entrance.

Charles Flynn, long-time associate of New York City mayor Ed Koch and son of Dr. Gene decided to leave politics and become actively involved in the family business.

"[4] The new gated park format, coupled with a rainy summer, led to a decline in attendance in the 1990 season.

[4] As some of the park's rides were auctioned off, a group of four local businessmen made an effort to purchase as many of them as possible.

However, by the 1996 season, a group called Summer Resorts, Inc., under the leadership of Gary Harris, completed a purchase of the park.

[5] The park reopened on July 4, 1996, but new problems arose in 1997 when Harris was convicted of tax evasion.

Several of the park's rides, including Devil's Den and Blue Streak, were repaired by volunteers.

In August 2010, the park received $50,000 in funds from a contest sponsored by Pepsi for use in restoring Blue Streak.

On August 6, 2016, both Cliffhanger Falls and Connie Otter's Kiddie Cove reopened to the public.

[36] Kiddieland was a small, enclosed section of the park, containing rides specifically for children.

The Kiddieland section of the park also offered pony rides in a small, circular, tethered track.