The song was released on November 8, 2019 and is an ode to getting to that comfortable stage in a relationship when you can let your guard down and stop worrying about trying to impress your love interest.

"[1] Michals added "It's just a fun, chill vibe that has a nice little groove to it and makes you smile and feel good.

[5] Chris Parton from Sounds Like Nashville said "it features the sonic swell of an epic romance in the making, anchored by crisp beats and soft-touch guitar riffs.

Equally plush are the two artists' vocal back-and-forth, with each asking the other to drop the 'cool' exterior they show the world".

[5] Mike Wass from Idolator described it as "a love song about being accepted for who you really are, 'Cool Anymore' is destined to strike a chord with couples from Nashville to New York".