Other early tenants included an Albertsons supermarket[3] and Woolworth, which was the last operational store in the state in 1993.

Starting in the early 2000s, Cottonwood Mall suffered high vacancy rates.

[6] A month later, the Holladay city council deemed the shopping mall blighted.

[8] Original redevelopment plans called for a lifestyle center to be built around the existing Macy's store.

[12] In 2017, Macy's announced that they would be closing the store located on the Cottonwood Mall property as part of a plan to restructure their U.S. operations.