G. C. Murphy became Meis, Elder-Beerman, and then Carson's, while Kmart moved out of the mall in 1993 and became a larger Sears store.

Following the closures of Carson's and JCPenney in 2018 and 2020 respectively, the mall's anchors are Rural King, Marshalls, Jo-Ann Fabrics, and Dunham's Sports.

[4] Both IGA and a branch of the Springfield, Illinois-based department store Myers Brothers opened on October 27.

[7] G. C. Murphy closed in 1976 and work began that year to convert the space to Meis, a department store based out of Terre Haute, Indiana.

[14] Bergner's closed at the mall after the Christmas 1989 shopping season, due to the space being too small for a full-line department store.

[23] Major tenants in the mall as of 2014 included Jo-Ann Fabrics, Bath & Body Works, Maurices, Christopher & Banks, Claire's, rue21, GNC and Shoe Dept.

[25] In 2017, the farming supply retail chain Rural King acquired the mall and announced plans to move a store support center into the former Sears.

[27] On July 12, 2018 Rural King announced they would move their Mattoon store into the former Sears location which opened on January 16, 2019.

[28] On August 31, 2018, Super Jumbo Buffet Chinese restaurant closed and was replaced by Scotty's Brewhouse which opened December 10, 2018.