[3] They subsequently moved to the Cliff in Larne as the NAFL require Premiership clubs to have "total control of their ground" in the event of ground-sharing.

They won this title again in 2008–09 and 2009–10 at which point they were promoted to Division 1C, the first level of the NAFL to be recognised as intermediate rather than junior.

[7] The club also made the final of the Border Cup in 2011–12, where they defeated higher division opposition in Islandmagee.

[11] The club qualified for the Irish Cup for the first time in 2011–12, reaching the third round by overcoming Lisburn Rangers and Abbey Villa before losing to Immaculata.

[13] Crumlin Star won the 2016–17 NAFL Premier Division title, finishing six points clear of second-placed Downpatrick.