[2] In 2011, a copy was discovered on Reddit and the ensuing reaction prompted TeenNick to re-air the film on October 31, 2011.

[3] Andrew (Jase Blankfort) and his older brother Carl (Trey Rogers) enjoy listening to ghost stories that the local undertaker, Mr. Bennett (Frank Langella), tells them.

One night Bennett tells the tale of a local farmer whose wife gave birth to conjoined twins, one being good-natured while the other was clearly evil.

[8] The supporting cast included:[9][10] The film was originally envisioned as a $10 million theatrical release for Nickelodeon, but it was instead ordered to be a made-for-television movie with a budget of $800,000.

The director originally wanted Tom Waits for the role of the caretaker, but Nickelodeon insisted on Frank Langella in hopes that it would garner extra publicity.

Cry Baby Lane was thought to be a lost film and gained a cult following due to its obscurity.

[2] The reaction from Reddit, as well as the success of the '90s Are All That, prompted TeenNick to re-air Cry Baby Lane on the night of October 31, 2011.