[9][10][11] In July 2012, the team held open tryouts for prospective players at the Inwood Soccer Center in Addison, Texas.

[14] The Sidekicks returned to the Allen Event Center for the 2013–14 PASL season with their home opener victory over the expansion Wichita B-52s on Saturday, November 2, 2013.

The Sidekicks also participated in the 2013–14 United States Open Cup for Arena Soccer, losing to Hidalgo La Fiera in the Round of 16.

Dallas was one of 23 teams in the new Major Arena Soccer League (MASL) and hosted the debut game on October 25, 2014, with the Missouri Comets visiting the Sidekicks at the Allen Event Center.

After falling to Missouri in the season opener, the team won 8 games in November and December before hitting a 4-game losing skid in January.

The Sidekicks regrouped and won 6 straight before closing the regular season with a loss to the Monterrey Flash, earning a 14–6 record overall.

The failure of the teams in Beaumont and Hidalgo, as well as regional rivals in Wichita and Tulsa, forced a league reorganization that placed Dallas in the Pacific Division of the Western Conference.

Central Division championships (1) As of September 18, 2022[17] Note: Flags indicate national team as defined under FIFA eligibility rules; some limited exceptions apply.