[1] He was named as a First Team All-New England Small College Athletic Conference (NESCAC) in his senior year.
[3] He graduated from Williams in 2001 with a Bachelor of Arts in history with a concentration in economics and political science.
[3] In 2001, DiCenzo was hired as the special teams coordinator and outside linebackers for Trinity (CT) under head coach Chuck Priore.
[2] In 2004 and 2006, he was named New England Collegiate Conference Wrestling Association (NECCWA) Assistant Coach of the Year.
[13] After Whalen resigned following the 2014 season to focus his efforts fully on his athletic director duties, DiCenzo was named head football coach.
[23][24][25][26] In 2024, he led the Cardinals to their first outright championship in school history and their first conference title since 2013 when they were co-champions.
[27][28] DiCenzo's 56 wins are good enough for fourth all-time in Wesleyan football history behind Norm Daniels (76), Frank Hauser (68), and Bill MacDermott (66).