[13] In September 2022 on Dynamite, Garcia defeated the BCC's Wheeler Yuta to win the ROH Pure Championship.

[14] Garcia lost the title back to Yuta at Final Battle in December 2022, ending his reign at 94 days.

[15] In 2023, Garcia unsuccessfully challenged Orange Cassidy for the AEW International Championship on two occasions, including in a four-way match at Forbidden Door.

[22] In November, Garcia called out MJF for the AEW World Championship,[23] but was defeated within ten minutes on an episode of Dynamite.

[24] On November 22, Garcia was announced as one of 12 competitors in the Continental Classic tournament, where he would compete in the Blue League.

[29] On the February 21 episode of Dynamite, it was announced Garcia would receive a TNT championship match on March 3 at Revolution.

[36] After a short hiatus, Garcia returned on the October 8 episode of Dynamite: Title Tuesday, where he announced that he had re-signed with AEW and had his continued sights set on championship gold.

[42] Garcia debuted for Pro Wrestling Guerrilla (PWG) at It's A Long Way To The Top (If You Wanna Rock 'n' Roll) on November 21, 2021, by losing to Jonathan Gresham via referee's decision.

[48][49] Garcia then participated in the 2023 Battle of Los Angeles, where he lost to Titus Alexander by disqualification in the opening round.

[51] Garcia then retained the World Championship against Battle of Los Angeles winner Mike Bailey in sudden death overtime in an Iron Man match at Twenty: Mystery Vortex by using underhanded tactics.he Vacated for the title in November 2023. he left company was 2023.

[55][56] This is a reference to his upset victory over "The American Dragon" Bryan Danielson by using the move at the Dynamite special Fight for the Fallen on July 27, 2022.

Following his entry into the JAS, Garcia rejected the label "professional wrestler" and embraced calling himself a sports entertainer,[57][58] a pejorative term used in AEW to denote a wrestling storytelling style that prioritizes showmanship.