Since joining the United Counties League, they have won promotion to the Premier Division on three occasions, but have also been relegated twice.

Prior to the start of the 2011–2012 Mark Kinsella was brought in and Ady Fuller moved on to become manager of Banbury United.

With a majority of the players remaining at the club for the 2013–14 season, the team made an incredible start to the campaign, winning their first 7 matches in the league whilst also qualifying for the FA Cup first round proper for the first time in their history.

[2] However, in June 2015, Iain Humphrey resigned as chairman and was replaced by Allan Smart, who relinquished his role as Daventry Town's manager in the process.

[4] However, Humphrey would make a U-turn and return as chairman just a month later, in July 2015, replacing Smart and caretaker manager Fuller who both left the club altogether.

[8] In April 2017, Daventry Town won the UCL Division One in their first season back at this level, going undefeated at home.

Arron Parkinson took on the role as manager and appointed former Woodford United and AFC Rushden & Diamonds keeper Matt Finlay as his assistant.

Pete Harris joined as coach and Andy Emery was announced as reserve team manager.

In 2021–22, the club moved to the Northern Premier League Division One Midlands ending the season in 16th place in the table.

The club also started a third male adult team playing in the Northants Combination League Division 3.

In 2021–22, the club moved to the Northern Premier League Midlands Division ending the season in 16th place but 15 points clear of the relegation spots.

Prior to the 2022/23 season, the club also started up an u18s side playing in the Northants Senior Youth League.

Note: Flags indicate national team as defined under FIFA eligibility rules; some limited exceptions apply.