[10] They lost the titles at Wrestle Kingdom 11 on 4 January 2017 to Los Ingobernables de Japón (Evil, Bushi and Sanada).

[20] On 14 October at King of Pro-Wrestling, Finlay made his return to the company, by making the save on Robinson who was being attacked by Lance Archer, after their match for the vacant IWGP United States Heavyweight Championship.

[22] At Showdown in Los Angeles, Finlay, Robinson and Clark Connors were defeated by Suzuki-gun (Minoru Suzuki, Archer and El Desperado).

After a 6-month absence from in-ring competition, Finlay made his Strong debut in August, participating in the inaugural New Japan Cup USA tournament.

[32] In April 2022, at Windy City Riot, FinJuice and Brody King defeated TMDK (Jonah and Shane Haste) and Bad Dude Tito in a 6-man tag-team street fight match.

[33] After Robinson turned heel by joining Bullet Club and breaking up FinJuice, Finlay focused on solely singles competition.

[36] On February 18, 2023, at Battle in the Valley, Finlay entered the ring to attack his former partner and longtime rival Jay White, after he was forced to leave NJPW, showing a more cocky and villainous persona.

At Dominion, Finlay (accompanied by Bullet Club's newest recruits Clark Connors, Drilla Moloney, Gabe Kidd and Alex Coughlin, as well as his manager Gedo) successfully defended the NEVER Openweight Championship against Phantasmo, after the stable's constant interference throughout the match.

[45] Afterwards, in a post-match interview, Ospreay proposed a three-way match between him, Moxley and Finlay at Wrestle Kingdom 18 for a new title.

On December 11, Sugabayashi revealed the new title would be the IWGP Global Heavyweight Championship, with the winner of the match becoming the inaugural champion.

[46] On January 4, 2024 at Wrestle Kingdom 18, Finlay defeated Moxley and Ospreay in a three-way match to become the inaugural IWGP Global Heavyweight Champion.

[48] The following month, Finlay took part in the 2024 New Japan Cup, where he made it to the quarter-finals, but was forced to withdraw from his tournament matchup with Hirooki Goto due to a health complaint before the match took place.

[49] On night 2 of Wrestling Dontaku, Finlay defeated Nemeth to win back the Global Heavyweight Championship for a second time.

[50] From July 20 and August 12, Finlay took part in the 2024 G1 Climax, where he won his block with a record of six wins and three losses, advancing to the semi-finals of the tournament.

[57] Finlay made his debut for Ring of Honor during the January 2019 TV tapings, in a loss to Tracy Williams.

[58] Robinson later announced the formation of Lifeblood, with the goal of bringing honor back to ROH; the stable included Finlay, Williams, Bandido, Mark Haskins and Tenille Dashwood.

[58] Lifeblood defeated Lethal's handpicked team of Jonathan Gresham, Flip Gordon, Dalton Castle and Jeff Cobb in the main event.

[60] On October 5, 2018, Finlay participated in Consejo Mundial de Lucha Libre's CMLL International Gran Prix, as part of the Resto del Mundo team, and as a representative of New Japan Pro-Wrestling.

[61][62] They feuded with The Good Brothers (Doc Gallows and Karl Anderson), defeating them at Sacrifice to win the Impact World Tag Team Championship.

[63] On the May 20 episode of Impact!, FinJuice lost the tag team titles to Violent By Design (Rhino and Joe Doering), ending their reign at 65 days.

[65] On the June 8, 2022 episode of Dynamite, Finlay made his debut for All Elite Wrestling (AEW), in a losing effort to Adam Page.

His brother Brogan is also a professional wrestler, and is currently signed to WWE, where he performs on the NXT brand under the ring name Uriah Connors.