Although Graye is American, he lived in the United Kingdom for all four years of high school before moving back to Pleasanton when he was 16.

Just a few months later he would be cast in the hit American crime drama Dexter, portraying the younger version of the titular character.

[3] In 2010, he starred longside John Cena, Patricia Clarkson, and Danny Glover in WWE Studios' film Legendary.

[4] He would also have a supporting role in the Disney Channel Original Movie Avalon High, an adaption of Meg Cabot's Arthurian fantasy novel.

The film centers on a young female switchboard operator who finds herself communicating with and possibly targeted by an active serial killer.

[17][18] The psychological thriller The Madness Inside Me was released in 2021, with Graye portraying a murderer being stalked by his victim's spouse.

[21][22] He also had an appearance in Jordan Peele's Western science fiction horror film Nope, as paparazzo Ryder Muybridge.

[25][26] A sequel for the hit 2015 science fiction psychological thriller Circle was announced in June 2024, with Graye writing the script.