[5] His Toffees team finished as runners-up in the Football League in the 1889–90 season and won the Liverpool Senior Cup.

[6] Everton went one better in the 1890–91 season, winning the Football League and retaining the Liverpool Senior Cup.

[6] Molyneux's tenure came to an end on 11 September 1901,[5] when he was suspended by the board of directors for suspected drunkenness.

[4] Later in the year, Molyneux was suspended from football until the end of the 1903–04 season for attempting to buy goalkeeper John Bishop out of the Scots Guards.

[2] He returned to Liverpool in June 1906 to be with his wife Anne and died a few days after arriving home.