The song was written by Cynthia Biggs, Carolyn Mitchell, Terence Dudley and Christopher Kellum, and produced by Ronnie Wilson and Dennis Charles.

A reviewer from Music Week gave "Don't You Love Me" four out of five, writing, "Unusually opening like a second cousin of The Persuaders theme, this breaks into one of Eternal's strongest singles yet.

"[4] Music Week editor Alan Jones described it as "a classy mid-tempo pop/R&B song hanging on a slightly changed but otherwise familiar bassline from the Dennis Edwards hit 'Don't Look Any Further'.

Designed to pluck at your heart strings like an over zealous army of crabs, police sirens, children singing, an old fashioned harpsichord-type-thing(?)

A great taster for their next album, 'Don't You Love Me', this proves that when it comes to R'n'B the girls are up there with En Vogue.