In 2008, members of the indie rock band Never Shout Never formed a post-hardcore side project called EatMeWhileImHot!.

The group released their debut extended play, All My Friends, on July 7, 2009 as Mister Owl.

The song "The Point" was released as a single on 200 limited edition CD-Rs on Never Shout Never's tour with the band, Hellogoodbye.

To support their new EP, the group started to perform shows as Mister Owl in the winter of 2009.

The album features an extreme metal sound rather than the experimental punk genres the band employed on every other release..

[4] The band likely disbanded as Ingle announced in December 2018 that Never Shout Never would dissolve after a small tour in Mexico and Brazil.