[1] They joined Junior Division One of the Exeter & District League in 1953, and were runners-up in their first two seasons.

[2] After finishing as runners-up again in 1959–60,[3] the 1960–61 season saw the club win the Devon Junior Cup,[4] the Football Express Cup,[5] and the Junior Division One East title, resulting in promotion to Senior Division One.

At the end of the 2012–13 season Elmore transferred to the Premier Division of the South West Peninsula League.

In 1958 they bought a plot of land named Slaughterhouse Field and built a new ground, Horsdon Park.

[1] In March 2011 the main stand was named after Adam Stansfield, a former player who went on to play professionally with Yeovil Town but died from cancer aged 31 in 2010.