They played in the Ohio League until 1919, and then became an independent team.
The team won the 1912 Ohio League championship, with an upset win over Peggy Parratt's Akron Indians.
Still the Athletics did continue to play APFA teams, including a Thanksgiving game against the Columbus Panhandles.
This American football team article is a stub.
You can help Wikipedia by expanding it.This article about a sports team in Ohio is a stub.