He won a second T&T PFL Championship winner's medal with San Juan Jabloteh in 2002 before signing with Al-Nejmeh in the Lebanese Professional League, where he quickly became one of the leading marksmen in that country.
He finished the 2003/2004 season with 15 goals, helping the club to the league title and a place in the 2004 AFC Cup.
After another brief stint in Lebanon with Al-Mabarrah and back home in Trinidad with St. Ann's Rangers, McFarlane signed a two-year deal with the Rochester Rhinos of the USL First Division on July 23, 2009,[1] but was let go after scoring only 2 goals in 12 appearances.
He was part of the qualifying team in the 2006 FIFA World Cup,[2] but was not selected in the final squad due to a late hamstring injury.
Errol is the brother of fellow professional Shem McFarlane, who plays for his former club St. Ann's Rangers.