At present, he competes on the PGA Tour Champions.

[1] His sole victory on the Nationwide Tour came at the 2005 Lake Erie Charity Classic at Peek 'n Peak Resort.

[2] Toledo has since won an additional three times on the Champions Tour at the 2013 Montreal Championship, 2015 Nature Valley First Tee Open at Pebble Beach and 2016 Allianz Championship.

Toledo's life and career is the subject of the book Tin Cup Dreams by Michael D'Antonio.

Nationwide Tour playoff record (0–1) PGA Tour Champions playoff record (3–0) Note: Toledo never played in the Masters Tournament or the PGA Championship.