The building is architecturally noted for its Romanesque and Gothic Revival features, and was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1989.

It is a roughly rectangular brick building, with a steeply pitched front-facing gable roof.

The building features are mainly Romanesque, with round-arch windows, paneled nave walls, and corbelled eaves.

However, it also has Victorian Gothic touches, including its front entry porch and polychromatic slate roof.

[2] The church was built in 1869 by the Hamilton Woolen Company for a nominally non-denominational congregation of its senior employees and owners.