After spending the first decade of their career on the Ferret Music label, they signed with Epitaph Records in 2008 and remained there until their split in early 2022.

The band also contributed an exclusive song to Redstar Records' Various Artists compilation The Sound and the Fury, released in October 1999.

[5] The band released Last Night In Town on August 14, 2001, and embarked on an east coast tour with Killswitch Engage in support.

The following March, the band embarked on tour with Unearth and Evergreen Terrace and shot a music video for the album's lead single, "Ebolorama" with director Darren Doane.

In 2004, Undecided Records reissued the band debut EP The Burial Plot Bidding War with an upgraded artwork and remastered audio.

He was replaced by Chris Byrnes of NORA who left the band immediately following their stint on Warped Tour 2006 under amicable circumstances.

[14] In February 2007, Keith Buckley stated that the band had been holed up in a basement in North Tonawanda, New York writing their fourth album.

Upon release of the album, Josh Newton replaced Harbin on bass and the band embarked on tour with Underoath, Poison The Well and Maylene and The Sons Of Disaster.

They also headlined the Take Action Tour, playing alongside From First to Last, August Burns Red, The Bled, and The Human Abstract.

At the end of June it was announced that drummer Mike "Ratboy" Novak had left the band due to "personal conflicts".

The band was part of the European Taste of Chaos tour at the end of 2009, supporting headliners Killswitch Engage and In Flames.

The band toured across Australia playing shows in Sydney, Gold Coast, Brisbane, Melbourne, Adelaide and Perth.

[24] In the spring of 2014, the band announced that they were starting production on their seventh studio album From Parts Unknown with producer Kurt Ballou, which was released July 8, 2014, along with their sixth run on the Vans Warped Tour 20th edition.

In February 2015, the band announced Ryan Leger's departure, and he was replaced by Daniel Davison, formerly of Norma Jean and Underoath.

In December 2015 while on tour with August Burns Red, Keith Buckley left due to a life-threatening emergency with his 7-month pregnant wife and unborn daughter.

It was during this time and the subsequent hospital stays that Buckley wrote a vast majority of lyrics for a new album while awaiting their clean bill of health and recovery.

[27][28] The band spent the next 2 years touring with the likes of Knocked Loose, Harm's Way, Fall Out Boy, Taking Back Sunday, '68, Motionless In White, Turnstile and Machine Gun Kelly in support of the album.

[35] In October 2018, the band announced that they would embark on one last tour in support of Low Teens with Turnstile, Angel Du$t and Vein.fm before taking time off to begin writing their ninth record.

The band completed recording before the COVID-19 pandemic escalated in the United States in early 2020, and waited to release the new album until they were able to tour in support of it.

[46] The rest of the members initially released a statement that they would finish the last three concerts of a late 2021 tour without him,[47] but the shows were canceled due to complications arising from COVID-19.

[47] In January 2022, days after canceling a UK tour, a joint statement from Jordan Buckley, Andy Williams, Stephen Micciche, and Clayton Holyoak confirmed the end of the band.

[61] On October 9, 2023, Keith Buckley announced that he had formed a new band with Charlie and Nick Bellmore (of Kingdom of Sorrow) called Many Eyes.