In the late sixties, the Hawks jumped to the Bluewater Junior Hockey League for a short stint.

This year the Hawks were not to be denied as they swept Bancroft 4-games-to-none to win the OHA Cup for the first time.

The next year, the Hawks again won the Western League and ran into the Lakefield Chiefs in the OHA Cup final.

The Chiefs overpowered the Hawks in the end, defeating Exeter in Game 7 of the series to claim the OHA Cup 4-games-to-3.

The playoffs for the 2019–20 season were cancelled due to the COVID-19 pandemic, leading to the team not being able to play a single game.