In 1992 Tyumen entered the newly formed Russian Premier League and finished last between 20 teams.

In 1993 Tyumen won the eastern zone of the First Division and returned to the Premier League for another two seasons, achieving their best result in history in 1994 (12th position).

In 2004 the club fielded a senior team as well, winning the zonal tournament of the Amateur League, but declined promotion.

[1] On 20 March 2019, 6 points in the standings were taken from Tyumen for unpaid debts to former players Marat Shaymordanov, Sergei Shumeyko and Nikita Fursin.

Note: Flags indicate national team as defined under FIFA eligibility rules; some limited exceptions apply.