[3] She played at the 2011 Military World Games volleyball tournament, winning the gold medal[4] and the Most Valuable Player and Best Spiker individual awards.

[5] Playing with Sollys Nestlé Osasco, Garay won the gold medal in the 2012 FIVB Club World Championship held in Doha, Qatar.

[9] After signing with the Russian club, Dinamo Krasnodar for 2014/2015,[10] Garay won the Russian Cup title[11] and the 2015 FIVB Club World Championship silver medal when her team lost to the Turkish Eczacibasi VitrA in the championship match.

[17] Garay won the silver medal at the 2015 Pan American Games when her national team was defeated in the championship match 0–3 by the United States.

[18] After winning silver at 2020 Summer Olympics, Garay announced her retirement from international competitions along with libero Camila Brait.