Built in 1864, it is a significant example of early Italianate ecclesiastical architecture in the state.

The church was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 2001.

A three-story tower projects from the center of the front facade, topped by a distinctive multistage copper-clad steeple.

The building's Italianate features include brackets in the gable and eaves, and round-headed windows on the second level.

They first met in rented space, before building their own edifice at Main and Church Streets in 1845.