The denomination was never large or broad-based in the city and was supported in part by the American Home Mission Society.

The church building is constructed of brick on a rock-faced stone basement.

The exterior bricks are painted white, and the primary ornamentation of the building are narrow, molded stringcourses and its stained glass windows.

It is defined more by its plain surface areas and clean, sharp lines.

Other features include short cornice returns, a pedimented roof dormer and palladian-like arrangement of the windows on the east side, all of which suggests Neoclassicism that was popular at the turn of the 20th-century.