[5][8][9] Three years later, the Andrew Carnegie Fund paid half the cost of a new organ.

[4][5][8] In 1916 the church was again remodeled,[4][5][8] and in 1926 and 1927 a parish house, educational center and social hall were added.

[3][8] In 1966, a new Fratelli Ruffatti organ was installed,[4][8] and four years later a Bach musical festival was presented.

[4][8] In 1982 the church was listed on the National Register for Historical Places,[3][8] an outdoor lighted sign was built and the west parking lot opened.

[1][3][8] The Shepherd's Garden was dedicated in 2007,[4][8] and traditional and contemporary worship services began.

[2] Under the terms of the transfer, First Church continued to meet in the building, and in 2019, it called the Rev.

Amy Rozko, a married couple and Anglican priests in the Diocese of Churches for the Sake of Others, as co-pastors.