It was built shortly after the congregation was established using the "open plan" interior favored by revivalists of the area as more conducive to worship.

The church's lot is elevated slightly above street level, giving it a good view of Pakatakan Mountain, the west end of Dry Brook Ridge, and other scenery east of the village.

The gable fields have fish-scale shingle siding; the roof's cornice is decorated with scroll-sawn vergeboards in a trefoil pattern and supporting brackets.

The upper stage has the belfry, with lancet arched balustrades and paneled corner piers topped with pinnacles above the eaves.

Near the front on the west side is a second double-doored entrance reached by a set of stone steps and, at ground level, a single door providing access to the basement at the corner.

Its furniture, apparently original, includes carved Eastlake chairs and a communion table, in addition to a piano and organ.

Architecturally, it is similar to other contemporary Presbyterian churches in Delaware County, such as New Kingston and West Kortright, both also listed on the National Register.

All are of frame construction, with corner bell towers and an eclectic assortment of features from various Victorian architectural styles.

The curved pews, radiating aisles and corner entrances maximized interior space, echoing the tents of the camp meeting.

The platform brought the preacher down from his high pulpit to closer contact with the worshippers, and gave him space to move around and keep the audience focused.